divine message

Can death by drowning be equal to death by suicide? The truth is becoming more and more confusing! ——Inscription As expected, the death of petitioner You Ji An, a village official, died unexpectedly. It was indeed a "drowning" death! (See the article "You Ji'an Case, There Can Be No Truth" written at the beginning of the month) Today (24th), the media briefing said that You Ji'an died of "drowning". Of course, this is an improvement compared to the "drowning suicide" announced by Xinhua County itself last time. Does this rule out the possibility of homicide? After all, this is a matter of life and death. Do the relevant departments have the responsibility to continue to investigate? The briefing provided basic responses to the questions left online by the family members of the deceased, but did not mention any requests made by the family members, such as asking the county government to avoid relevant parties and publishing relevant photography and videos. The matter seems to have been finalized, and the coffin can be closed! In fact, the case is not clear, but more complicated, more doubtful, and more bizarre! As I said last time, this case is not just as simple as verifying the cause of death. It has actually risen to the level of a political issue. No matter what the conclusion of this case is, in the so-called long-term overall situation, the government is the loser! It's just that this result is extremely difficult for the victim's family to accept! It is said that today's briefing meeting was held in Loudi City. Many outsiders and many locals spontaneously went to the scene to listen to the briefing. However, according to insiders: There was a media briefing in Loudi this afternoon. Many people spontaneously took the car to Loudi and were stopped on the road by the relevant departments! The disabled team that the deceased You Jian had participated in "wanted to go to Loudi City, but was controlled by the relevant departments of Xinhua County, and the traffic leading to Loudi was controlled." Haha, it can be said that it is a massive effort. I don't know, our people's government, what are you afraid of? ? At the same time, relatives of the deceased also raised questions: Why were the family members not notified in advance when the briefing meeting was held? Why was not even the wife of the deceased allowed to attend the briefing? Why are the interview media designated by the government and other media cannot come in? Why don't the media appointed by the government even listen to the painful voices of the relatives of the deceased? The ZF, which is facing a formidable enemy, is actually here and has lost an opportunity! Judging from the entire briefing, the spokesperson repeatedly mentioned and adopted the testimony of ZF security guards, while turning a deaf ear to the testimony provided by the relatives of the deceased and the public response to the deceased in the village of the deceased! The core of the briefing was centered around the autopsy, giving the impression that: first presuppose the conclusion, and then use the conclusion to deduce the cause! ——The one-month preparation is not in vain, and it is also perfect! I don't know if this is legal or common sense? ! The briefing meeting also rescued the Family Planning Office and the electric power company, and also cleared the relationship with them. It was said that You Ji'an had been compensated for his minor disability, and You Ji'an also signed it. The power company's job was a normal dismissal, and compensation was given, and You Ji'an also signed it "happily"! This is a bit inexplicable. If this is true, Yu Ji'an has repeatedly gone to the top and even petitioned to Beijing. Isn't this because he is full? After the briefing, relatives of the deceased then raised questions: 1. Why has the relevant surveillance video of the fifth and sixth floors of the County ZF on June 8 and the surveillance video of the County ZF leading to Youjia Town on the 9th not been released so far? 2. If the deceased died of drowning, when was the time of his death? Where was the fall into the water? Was it suicide or homicide? 3. Why were the town government staff's testimonies inconsistent after the incident? 4. Why would the security guard throw a "living person" into the trunk? Is this a normal way to treat living people? 5. Why did the investigation team only accept the testimony of the security guard who had a very close interest in the deceased? Yes, in fact, these questions are not difficult to answer, so why are they so secretive? There is this sentence in the report: "At about 10 pm, Zeng Xiangwen, director of the Dongling District of Youjia Town, came to persuade him to leave. He worked until about 11 pm, but you lay on the ground and refused to listen." Does You Ji'an have epilepsy? Would you lie on the floor without any external stimulation? It seems that the government has great power and is turning everything upside down, but in fact our government has lost another opportunity!Investigating the underlying reasons, I found that a netizen wrote better, and I have transcribed it below: Author: Cambrian Bu Leng Another murder case occurred after petitioning a village official, this time in Xinhua, Hunan. According to a report in the Yangcheng Evening News titled "Hunan petitioner village official suspected of being beaten to death and dumped: Provincial leader orders thorough investigation", Youji'an, a village cadre from Foguang Village, Youjia Town, Xinhua County, Loudi City, Hunan Province, went to the government compound to petition. When he went there, he drove his own car, and when he came out, he was lying on his back and carried into the trunk of an off-road vehicle. Later, his body was found in the river. The passing of a life always makes people sad, hoping that he can reach the paradise world. Let's go back to the case itself and use the interest analysis method to predict the direction and possible results of the case. You Ji'an's death forced the family to reveal the truth, and staff from the county government office were directly involved in the case. The current parties with opposing interests are the county government and the family of the deceased. The county government said that this matter has nothing to do with us, because first, the deceased was in good condition when he left the town, as evidenced by the video; second, the autopsy report stated that the deceased did not have any trauma on his body, so he could not have been beaten to death. The family members said that he was beaten to death by government personnel because, first, two chest ribs were broken in the deceased's body, there were blood clots on the back of his head, and there were many bruises on the skin all over his body. Second, the video was not installed on the fourth floor where the deceased stayed and refused to leave, so it cannot be proven that the deceased refused to leave on his own. Third, the family members do not believe that the video that proves the deceased left the town is the deceased himself. This case is actually not complicated, because the autopsy report makes it easy to figure out the cause of death: the internal tissues of the deceased are different from those of people thrown into the water after death (for example, the lungs of a drowned person will be swollen, and there will be substances in the river water in the lungs). But the strange thing was that the time of death in June had not been resolved by November. Can the truth come out after media reports? We analyze this and try to draw forward-looking conclusions. Since the media intervened, the case has changed from the original two parties to three parties, namely: relatives and friends of the deceased, the local government and the public opinion media. Let's first analyze their interests involved in this incident. The family members of the deceased have interests in finding out the truth, seeking justice, and obtaining financial compensation. The most important ones are the first two (because the county government has promised to provide them with financial supplements but has not agreed). The interest of local governments is to maintain stability. The interests of the media, which represent public opinion, are to reveal the truth, safeguard justice, expand media influence, and increase media sales. Behind the organization are people, behind the government are the people working in the government, and they have their own economic, political, and social interests; behind the media are people, too, and they also have their own economic and social interests. The county government and the family of the deceased are directly opposing parties in the game of interest. Judging from media reports, the game between them is likely to be a zero-sum game: a win for one party means a loss for the other party. For those involved in the government, winning can keep their jobs; losing means not only losing their jobs, but also going to jail. For the family members, if they win, they will find out the truth and seek justice; if they lose, they will feel guilty for the deceased. The media is a relatively detached third party. Their purpose is to stir up hot topics of public opinion and help uncover the truth by leveraging social attention. Since the family of the deceased is on the weaker side, the media will increase moral and information support to bring the strengths of both parties as close as possible. It is impossible to reveal the truth solely by relying on the county government, the family of the deceased and the media. Although the county government has public power, because it is a direct stakeholder, any of its conclusions will lose credibility and be difficult to convince the opposing party; the family of the deceased and the media have no public power and no investigative power. Public opinion alone can only exert pressure, but it is impossible to reveal the truth. Therefore, the intervention of higher-level powers is an inevitable requirement. Therefore, the provincial government had to intervene. After the provincial government intervenes, can the truth be revealed? Let's take a look at the interest relationship after the intervention of the provincial government. After the provincial government intervened, its main stakeholder was the county government. The interests of the provincial government and the county government are both consistent and conflicting.What is consistent is that they all want to maintain local stability and the credibility of the government. The point of conflict is that if you join You Ji'an and you are really beaten to death, the provincial government may maintain local stability and the credibility of the government by sacrificing county government personnel, and relevant county government personnel will be imprisoned. After the provincial government intervened, the county government's job was to cooperate with the investigation. The pressure from the family of the deceased and the media and public opinion naturally focused on the provincial government. If the investigation proves that You Ji'an died of drowning, it will be a great blessing for both the county government and the family of the deceased (although it is extremely unfortunate for the deceased). The county government passed the test smoothly, and the family of the deceased has nothing to blame. The media has nothing to lose. If the investigation proves that You Ji'an was really beaten to death and his body thrown into the water, the county government may lose miserably: both those who did it and those who ordered it will be jailed, and the credibility of the county government will be seriously affected. If the situation falls into the former category, the county government does not need to worry at all; if the situation falls into the latter category, how should the county government respond? The county government has two coping strategies: one is to do nothing and wait for the results to come out, and then the relevant personnel will go to jail obediently; the other is to take the initiative and use the common interest of maintaining local stability with the provincial government to persuade the leaders to revise the investigation conclusions. According to the law of maximization of interests: individuals will seek the best interests for themselves in all activities. The latter strategy is the only choice for county government personnel. If they choose to persuade the leader, is the leader likely to be persuaded by them? Let's look at the interests of provincial leaders. Currently, maintenance of local stability and economic development are the two most important indicators for promotion of government officials. However, the inexplicable death of a villager is not included in the inspection items at all, and whether there is a sense of justice cannot be included in the inspection items. In other words, from the perspective of individual actual interests, provincial leaders will not care at all how You Ji'an died, but they will care about whether his death will affect local stability and economic development. However, the provincial government may be worried that if the truth is exposed, it will get in trouble, and if the people below are unable to report, it will also bring disaster to the investigators. Therefore, county government personnel must ensure that if something goes wrong, they must carry it themselves. If you don't do this, you will definitely face jail; as long as you bear the risk, you can get through safely, not to mention that according to China's national conditions, this risk is very small. Let's look at it again. If an unpublished investigation proves that You Ji'an was beaten to death and his body was thrown into the river, how should the provincial government deal with it? The first is to make the truth known to the public, and then deal with relevant county government officials in accordance with the law. The advantage of this is that it maintains the credibility of the provincial government, but the disadvantage is that the credibility of the county government is damaged, which affects the county's economic development (who dares to invest there now), and may lead to even more uncontrollable situations (government employees directly beating citizens to death, how bad the impact can be imagined?). The other is to modify the investigation conclusion to "prove" that You Ji'an died of drowning. The disadvantage of this is that it conceals the truth and undermines justice, and unless the risk after the truth is exposed can be controlled at the county government level, the results will be even worse, but the advantage is that it "maintains" social stability and consolidates economic development. Obviously, as long as the truth is not exposed or the risks are controllable after exposure, then it is obviously more beneficial than harmful to the above to modify the investigation report. So, let's look at whether it is feasible not to expose the truth? As things stand, the only thing that can prove the cause of death is an examination of the body. Even if I guess based on my amateur level, it is feasible to manipulate the autopsy report whether the autopsy is performed within the province or outside the province. The examination of the corpse can be divided into two parts, one is the examination of the body shell, and the other is the examination of the internal organs. The conclusions of both parts are manipulable. As for the rib fractures, the police have said that they were "retained when forensic personnel removed tissue from the body" (what an amateur autopsy examiner); as for the congestion on the back of the brain, the police have said that they are "just blood tissue remaining under the scalp of the deceased", so this part is not difficult to deal with.As for the internal organs, either replace the internal organs and let others test them, or simply say that they were eaten by dogs (it is nothing more than a punishment). Anyway, it really can't be concealed. The county government can just keep it secret, while the provincial government has only a small risk. As for the issue of video recording and time asymmetry, doubts remain doubts. No one saw Yu Ji'an being thrown into the river with their own eyes. What can you do? The relatives and friends of the deceased have no way to appeal (the above reports have come out, aren't you making trouble unreasonably?); all the media can do is analyze and speculate for a few days, and the attention is soon diverted by other issues. To sum up, as long as there are no other circumstances, no matter how You Ji'an died,